It must be difficult to emerge from the
shadow of a ten-year-long, critically acclaimed project as prolific
as The Books. Few solo projects reach the heights of the acts that
begot them, and in Nick Zammuto's case, the hope here is that his new
output – creatively titled “Zammuto” - will somehow be
comparable to one of the most innovative and beloved projects in
experimental pop and sound collage in the last decade. It would be
nice if it was possible to separate the two acts and evaluate this
new venture on its own individual terms, but the reality is that
there's probably no one who will write about Zammuto (the band)
without mentioning Zammuto (the musician's) resume, and in this case
especially, it's extremely difficult to avoid.
Nick Zammuto has a lot going for his
first self-titled album. Some of the elements and ideas that made
The Books' recordings so compelling make appearances here from time
to time - the curated snippets of bizarre audio from anonymous
sources, carefully constructed but sometimes chaotic sounding
progression, digitally processed vocals, exacting wit and clever
wordplay. There are a few songs (“Too Late Topologize”
“Harlequin” “The Shape Of Things To Come”) which would be
right at home on any Books record, and then there are those that
would somehow not. These contain a kind of straight-forwardness
that obliterates the mystery, beauty, precision, and whimsy that made
The Books what it is. At best, the indignant, driving undertones of
“F U C-3PO” improve on the ambiguity that marked Zammuto's prior
work (though what he has against beloved the Star Wars character is
not made apparent). But at its most cloying, the jam-band tendencies
of “Groan Man, Don't Cry” might make some Books fans want to
groan and cry, and the disembodied female androids “rapping”
through the entirety of “Zebra Butt” seem, well, asinine.
Overall, however, the record is a triumphant experiment in the same
spirited vein as the music Zammuto made as one half of The Books, yet
sets itself apart just enough for these explorations and new
additions to remain interesting (stream it below via the band's soundcloud).
Nick Zammuto met Paul de Jong in 1999
as tenants in the same New York City apartment building, but it
wasn't until six years and two and half albums later that they
finally started touring, screening unique and often hilarious video
collages of found material during the shows. For Zammuto, Nick's
wasted no time in assembling a group of considerably talented band
members and embarking on a proper tour, borrowing some elements from
his former musical project but creating something that is wholly
different. That tour culminated at Glasslands last Monday, with
Lymbyc Systym opening.
Lymbyc Systym is a two piece that
sounds like a band five times its size. Hailing from Tempe, Arizona
(but now based in Brooklyn), brothers Jared and Michael Bell make
earnest, transcendent post rock. Their intricate compositions are
thought out to the most minute detail and replicated live with
stunning exactness. Having not released an album since 2009, this
particular set featured plenty of new material, much of it tinged
R&B beats and influences. Though there's very little to see
onstage – Jared hunches over some electronic equipment, while
Michael drums beneath a swath of dark curls – the sounds they make
take on a breathing, seething life of their own, instantly occupying
every inch of space from floor to ceiling. While the nostalgic
undertones are at some points crushing, there is no room for
pretentiousness and it never really has a chance to rear its head.
For having played with so many huge names in indie rock, the pair
have remained humble, and that nonchalance somehow makes their music
seem that much more potent. They were joined on stage for a few
songs by a friend with a violin, the strings adding sweetness and
drama in just the right amounts.
When Zammuto took the stage it was not
Nick as soloist, but Zammuto as a full band, joined by brother Mikey
on bass, Sean Dixon on drums, and Gene Back (who had also played
intermittently with The Books) on keys and additional guitars. Like
an actual extension of the mood introduced by album's first track
(entitled “Yay”) there was a collective, ecstatic enthusiasm so
apparent it could have been a fifth band member. The sense that it
gave me was so different from having seen The Books; whereas The
Books wanted to tickle at thought processes, Zammuto's live show is
all about the act of playing. Nick in particular seems so motivated
by desire to expand on a live sound and share it with anyone willing
to bear witness that it's hard not to respect - though it is
slightly ironic when you consider that he manufactures most of these
sounds by himself, holed up in a shed behind the eco-house which he
inhabits with his wife and children in the sprawling countryside of
rural Vermont.
In terms of visual stimuli, Zammuto
also had something to offer, though the projections here were less
choreographed and a bit more random that the video pairings I'd seen
at Books shows. A bit more akin to Found Footage Fest or Everything
is Terrible, the first projection was a chopped and screwed how-to
for finger skateboarding, while another took stock photos of actors
“experiencing” back pains, headaches, and otherwise twisting
their faces and contorting their bodies into unpleasant shapes. But
the most intriguing video was one that actually formed a song – for
“The Greatest Autoharp Solo of All Time”, Zammuto took the sights
and sounds of a Bob Bowers-led instructional video for the autoharp
player, editing the song “Battle Hymn of the Republic” until it
was all but unrecognizable. The band played alongside the video,
drawing on its unique rhythms to form a cohesive, moving piece with
just a hint of a clever smirk.
The only real low-point of the show,
for me, was a crunchy version of Paul Simon's “50 Ways To Leave
Your Lover” that fell flat mostly because it lacked imagination and
also because in Paul Simon's oeuvre “50 Ways” has got to be one
of the weakest, most trite tunes.
The encore of Zammuto's set was the big
payoff for fans expecting another Books show. In attempting to
present “Zebra Butt” live, there had been some unexplained
technical difficulties. Nick had promised to come back to it, even
offering to hook up another computer that supposedly would have had
the necessary files. For whatever reason, these plans were to no
avail and resulted in one of the most awkward interstices between set
and encore I've ever observed. But out of that wreckage came the
first twangs of “Smells Like Content”, the seminal philosophical
love-letter to living from 2005's Lost And Safe. I've been trying to
decide whether this was a cheap shot – if picking out the most
instantly recognizable and moving track that you've built your
musical career on as an encore to one of your new band's first shows
is somehow a weak move. Would I have felt more gratified if he'd
chosen a “deep cut” as opposed to a “hit”? Did I feel
slightly pandered to, being reminded in such an obvious way of one of
the greatest contributions The Books made to independent music? Yes,
but also no.
There's this beautiful and sort of
tragically funny truism that appears as a sound-byte at the end of
the recorded version of “Smells Like Content” (Expectation
leads to disappointment. If you don't expect something big, huge,
and exciting.... usually uhhhh... I don't know... you're just not
as... yeah) and though Zammuto didn't roll the clip at the end of
playing the song, its unforgettable to anyone who's listened to that
song as much as I have. Thinking of it served almost as a caution
not to expect Books-caliber output from only half of the band, that
it would by its nature be the same in some ways, different in others,
and there was simply no reason to obsess over the particulars when
you should just try to enjoy it. While the high-minded creativity
that propelled The Books is present in some aspects of this project
and absent in others, Zammuto (as a band) is a new iteration in that
direction. Even if in the end Zammuto doesn't feel as wholly
imagined as its predecessor (because one half of it is literally
missing), there's plenty of merit and beauty in the music that Nick
Zammuto is still more than willing to create. And whether its fair
or not to evaluate this album against The Books' releases will stop
being a question the longer he continues to produce work and come
into his own, shedding those expectations and freeing himself for
further sonic exploration.